Silicone Hydrogel vs Hydrogel Contact Lenses: Which Material Is Right for You?
18th Nov 2026
Both materials are well proven, and both are safe to wear when they're properly fitted and looked after. The big difference is oxygen: silicone hydrogel lenses let far more oxygen through to the front of your eye than traditional hydrogel lenses do.
Whether that makes them more comfortable is far less certain. A Cochrane review found wearers may find either material similarly comfortable, although the evidence was of very low certainty.
So there's no single "best" material. The right one depends on your prescription, how long you wear your lenses, whether you ever sleep in them, your eye health and how your eyes respond. Australian research also shows your wearing habits and lens care often matter more than the material itself. Your optometrist is the right person to make the call.
Quick comparison
| Hydrogel | Silicone hydrogel | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Soft, water-absorbing plastic (traditionally HEMA-based) | Hydrogel combined with silicone |
| How oxygen gets through | Mainly dissolved in the water held in the lens | Largely through the silicone, so much more oxygen passes through |
| Oxygen permeability | Lower | Much higher |
| Comfort | Many people find it comfortable | Many people find it comfortable. No clear evidence either is better for everyone |
| Feel | Generally softer | Generally a stiffer material |
| Overnight wear | Lower oxygen supply, so overnight wear is generally avoided | Some are designed for extended wear, but sleeping in any lens raises infection risk |
| Often found in | Many daily disposable lenses | Daily, fortnightly and monthly lenses, including many toric and multifocal options |
How the two materials differ
Hydrogel lenses are made from a water-absorbing plastic, traditionally HEMA (poly-2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate). Oxygen reaches your cornea (the clear front surface of your eye) by dissolving in the water inside the lens. That's why these lenses generally have a higher water content but much lower oxygen permeability.
Silicone hydrogel lenses were developed to dramatically boost oxygen flow. Silicone is very good at letting oxygen through, while the hydrogel components keep the lens soft and moving freely on the eye.
Silicone hydrogel is now the most commonly prescribed type. International prescribing surveys covering more than 260,000 daily wear soft lens fits across 20 countries found silicone hydrogel rose from 2.8% of fits in 2000 to 73.7% in 2023. Between 2019 and 2023 it averaged 73% of fits, with hydrogel making up most of the rest.
Keep in mind these are international figures, not Australian ones. The researchers suggested the split between the two may now be levelling out, so hydrogel is still very much in everyday use.
Oxygen is the biggest difference, but does it matter?
In short, it matters a lot for some wearers, but less than many people assume for everyday daily wear.
Your cornea has no blood supply, so a lens that restricts oxygen can put it under stress. There are two terms you might hear from your optometrist.
- Dk is how permeable the lens material is to oxygen
- Dk/t is how much oxygen actually passes through the finished lens, which also depends on its thickness (t)
Here's what that means in practice.
- Silicone hydrogels have largely solved low-oxygen (hypoxia) problems. A major evidence review, the BCLA CLEAR report on lens materials, noted that better oxygen permeability has meant hypoxia-related problems have largely been negated in many countries.
- For daily wear, plenty of people do well in either material. In the Cochrane review, daily disposable silicone hydrogel and hydrogel lenses showed no clinically meaningful difference in corneal staining or redness, although the certainty was very low.
- Higher oxygen matters more in some situations. These include long wearing hours, higher prescriptions (which can mean thicker lenses) or signs of oxygen stress in your eyes. Your optometrist can check for this.
Comfort and dryness
Is silicone hydrogel more comfortable? It depends on your eyes. Comfort is personal, and many people find either material comfortable.
Getting comfort right matters, because eye discomfort is the number one reason people give up soft contact lenses for good. The good news is that it can often be fixed with the right lens, material or wearing schedule. The Cochrane review (seven trials, including some run in Australia) found no clear difference in comfort between the two materials. However, the evidence was very uncertain, most trials were at high risk of bias, and most didn't use a validated comfort measure. The authors concluded there wasn't enough evidence to recommend one material over the other.
A few other things are worth knowing.
If your lenses feel dry or uncomfortable, let your optometrist know rather than putting up with it. A small change is often all it takes.
Safety comes down to more than the material
Contact lens complications are common, affecting around a third of wearers, though most are mild and easy to manage. Serious infection (microbial keratitis) is rare but can threaten your sight. A large Australian study estimated it affects about 4.2 in every 10,000 wearers each year. Here's what it found.
- Overnight wear was the major risk factor, whatever the lens material. Sleeping in your lenses is the single biggest thing to avoid, unless your optometrist has specifically told you otherwise.
- Other risk factors included poor lens case hygiene and smoking. The study also found a higher risk among people who bought their lenses online. Optometry Australia has said it has no issue with buying online with a valid prescription, and that this risk may reflect differences in lens care attitudes and behaviours. The takeaway is simple. Wherever you buy, get a proper fit, keep your prescription up to date and stay on top of your check-ups.
- Climate played a part. A separate Australian study found severe infections were more likely in warmer, humid parts of the country. That's worth knowing if you live in, or travel to, the tropics.
In the Cochrane review's extended (overnight) wear trials, hydrogel lenses may have had a lower risk of adverse events over 52 weeks than silicone hydrogel. But only two trials were included, and the certainty was very low. Either way, sleeping in lenses carries extra risk, so it's a decision to make with your optometrist.
Good habits for Australian conditions
- Never use tap water on your lenses or case, and take your lenses out before swimming (pool or ocean) or showering
- Wash and dry your hands before handling your lenses
- Replace your lenses and case as directed
- Don't wear lenses past their replacement date
Which material might suit you?
These are general guides only. Your optometrist will tailor their advice to you.
Silicone hydrogel may suit you if:
- You wear lenses for long hours most days
- You have a higher prescription
- Your optometrist has noticed signs of oxygen stress
- You need a design that mainly comes in silicone hydrogel, such as many fortnightly and monthly lenses, and some toric (astigmatism) and multifocal options
Hydrogel may suit you if:
- You wear lenses part-time, especially as daily disposables
- Silicone hydrogel feels stiff or less comfortable on your eyes
- Your optometrist suggests switching to help with a lens-related reaction
Material and replacement schedule are two separate choices
"Silicone hydrogel vs hydrogel" is about what the lens is made of. "Daily vs fortnightly vs monthly" is about how often you replace it. Both materials come in daily lenses.
Not sure which suits you? Our guide to fortnightly vs monthly contact lenses breaks down the differences. If you also need astigmatism correction, browse our toric contact lenses. For presbyopia, see our multifocal contact lenses or read what multifocal lenses can do for presbyopia.
Once you and your optometrist have settled on a lens, a contact lens subscription can keep your supply in step with your replacement schedule.
Choosing contact lenses in Australia
Your prescription names the lens. In Australia, prescription contact lenses are medical devices regulated by the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA). Your prescription is based on a fitting and specifies the lens you were assessed in. You can then find that exact lens by browsing brands such as Acuvue, Alcon, Bausch + Lomb and CooperVision.
Don't swap brands or materials on your own. Optometry Australia has warned that switching to a different brand or style without a check-up can mean a different fit or different material characteristics. If you'd like to change, see your optometrist first.
Book a proper fitting. New to contact lenses or changing materials? Read our guide to your first contact lens fitting in Australia. To find an optometrist near you, try Optometry Australia's Find an optometrist tool.
Check your health fund. Many private health extras policies pay benefits towards contact lenses, depending on your fund and level of cover. See our health funds page.
Keep up your check-ups. Your eyes and prescription can change over time, and regular aftercare is part of wearing lenses safely.
Questions to ask your optometrist
- Is silicone hydrogel, hydrogel, or either, right for my eyes and prescription?
- Do I have any signs of oxygen stress or dryness that affect the choice?
- How many hours a day should I wear my lenses, and which replacement schedule suits me?
- Which care solution should I use (for non-daily lenses)?
- If my lenses are uncomfortable, what should I try first, and when should I come back?
When to see an eye care professional
Take your lenses out and get prompt professional advice (from your optometrist, GP, or a hospital emergency department if it's urgent) if you notice:
- A red, painful or light-sensitive eye
- Discharge, or a feeling that something is stuck in your eye
- Sudden blurry vision or vision loss
- Discomfort that doesn't settle after you remove the lens
Contact lens-related infections can threaten your sight, so don't wait and "see how it goes".
Frequently asked questions
This article is general information only and isn't a substitute for professional advice. Always consult a registered optometrist or doctor about your eyes. Always read the label and follow the directions for use.
References
- https://www.contactlensjournal.com/article/S1367-0484(24)00203-0/fulltext
- https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD014791.pub2
- https://old.myopiaprofile.com/?p=18639
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clae.2021.02.006
- https://www.optometry.org.au/patient_care_management/optometry-australia-concerned-at-rise-of-unvalidated-online-contact-lens-sales/
- https://tga.gov.au/sites/default/files/submission-consultation-changes-definitions-scope-md-framework-oa.pdf
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clae.2021.02.010
- https://www.aao.org/education/editors-choice/overnight-contact-lens-wear-remains-major-risk-fac
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajo.2007.06.037